Niko said:
Get some good quality LED bulbs like BEAMtech or Faren. Install them properly and you’ll have zero glare for drivers. Sharp cutoff lines and more light.
Done that in my daughter’s 2016. Good LEDs have the right light pattern, better long-distance output, are lower cost, and last much longer than high-output halogen bulbs.
Okay, so I might be a bit clueless. I went out with a heater and a headlamp, took my time getting it back in. I still don’t feel 100% sure, but it seems like only two of the notches were in right. I fiddled with it more and now it has the same pattern as the other. Good news is I’ll have to do this again soon after playing around with the bulb so much.